Please post on your choice of reading in this category. Remember, you are reading like a media specialist, so it is not about your personal likes and dislikes. Include in your post:
a. Audience for whom the book is written
b. Audience to whom it will appeal (might differ from a)
c. Particular strengths of the book
d. Particular weaknesses of the book
e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.)
f. And, in School Library Journal's format: your verdict supported with details
No plot summaries and no spoliers, please. Failure to follow that rule will result the revocation of your authoring rights, guaranteed!!!
The book Starfish was written for ages 10-13, or grades 4-6. I believe this book brings any adult reader back into the painful feeling of powerlessness, and of childhood cruelty coming from peers, family, and yourself. It also reminds us of the amazing feeling of standing up for yourself and stepping into your power and self love. For this reason, adults would be moved and enjoy reading the book. I also think anyone who has experienced how the world treats you when you are fat would feel validated and encouraged by this book. The strengths of the book are showing young people that the beliefs of the people around you, including your parents, can be wrong. It is one of few messages overtly saying that there is nothing wrong with being fat, contrary to many of the messages we may receive. It also normalizes and shows the advantages of therapy, as well as having good friends. Lastly, it being written in verse makes it a powerful and approachable read. This is not exactly a weakness, but I would love for Fipps to write a similar accompanying novel for high school aged readers. Although the experience of being shamed and bullied for being fat is certainly present at age 11, not everyone is able to have the support and lessons to rise up so bravely quite as early on in life. There are a lot of people who continue to struggle and have negative self-talk about their weight well into later adolescence and adulthood. This book also taps into the cultural experience of living in Texas as a Mexican-American, and the stereotypes that can follow those circumstances. A courageous feel good read, Starfish is a must purchase for any library with tween aged readers, for its fat positive messaging and close look at how self love is grown.
ReplyDeleteThis book has been on my list for a while now so I'm happy to read your positive review!
DeleteI think that is well observed Lizzie that this topic could be explored differently at the HS level. You might be interested in reading Love is a Revolution by Renee Watson. That is not a book told in free verse, but it does explore body image in the eyes of ones self and others while finishing HS.
DeleteThe One Thing You'd Save by Linda Sue Park
ReplyDeleteAudience & Appeal: This book was written for 8 to 12 year olds but could easily be enjoyed by people of all ages.
STRENGTHS: This book is written in sijo form (a Korean verse similar to a haiku) and could be used in classrooms as a great discussion or start of a poetry unit. It was a short and simple book, and although there wasn’t a lot of detail there was some emotion behind the stories that the students shared about the items they would save. Reviews mentioned that the black and white illustrations were well done, however I listened to the audio book so I missed those.
WEAKNESSES: Some readers may struggle with who is sharing each part of the dialogue because it’s unclear (I listened to the audio book and didn’t notice this as being an issue). There wasn’t much of a plot, but it felt more like a story than just a poem, and the characters were only developed with the information they shared about what they would save.
CURRICULUM: This could connect to a poetry unit or writing lesson.
VERDICT: I thought this was a good book and would likely add it to the collection. As a classroom teacher I could see using this book to engage students in a writing assignment and discussion. I think that the illustrations and short length would draw students to the book, as well as the topic. Students may not walk away loving the book, but it could be an on-ramp to a new genre.
I agree, this book is short and simple, but would be great for writing prompts. If you do have a student who has experienced loss through a fire, it could have content that triggers an emotional response.
DeleteBefore the ever after
ReplyDeleteby Jacqueline Woodson
Gr 4-8 Zacharia Junior is a boy who is proud of his father, who is a football star. This is a novel written in verse form and winner of the Coretta Scott King Award. The story is set in the year 1999, in New York and is divided into two parts. In the first part of the book, Z Junior admires and is proud of his father for the sports achievements he has in his life. However, his father's attitude becomes aggressive and moody all the time. At the end of this first part, the father suffers an attack, and the police arrive at his house.
In the second part we discover that Z's father has several brain tumors. As we advance in the reading in verse, we perceive that the life and mind of his father wears out and falls like the leaves on the maple tree that they both observe over and over again through the window of their house. The description of aggressiveness and mental deterioration are well described.
A relevant characteristic of what Z Junior narrates is that we can sense his sadness at seeing his father losing his mind. The arguments at home do not stop. The loneliness and melancholy of this child spends listening to blue songs on the radio, waiting for doctors and accepting that his father will not get better. VERDICT I see no weaknesses in this book. On the contrary, this is a compelling novel about compassion and humanity towards a loved one who is seriously ill.
Did you find yourself having to climb back into 1999 and remember that at the time, athletes were having symptoms but the cause was not yet known?
DeleteThis was one of my favorite reads this semester! Jude was such an easy character to get behind and her experiences throughout the book will teach many students more about the migration experience and expand understanding for anyone who is not an immigrant.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your reflections Karina!
oh thanks, Beth. Jude is an amazing character
DeleteThe Long Way Down by Jason Reynolds
ReplyDeletea. Audience for whom the book is written: This is a young adult book. I found numerous recommendations for high school and up, and 14 and up.
b. Audience to whom it will appeal: I agree with the recommended ages I found through Common Sense Media and Title Wave, ages 14 and up, although a savvy 12 year old could also appreciate this title as well.
c. Particular strengths of the book: This is not a particularly long book, at 306 pages. As Will tells his story over the course of just over a 60 second ride down to the ground floor on an elevator the reader gets a chance to think about the choice Will has to make. Whether to avenge the death of his brother, or not.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: none that I noted
e. Any special considerations: Throughout the book, characters engage in smoking, talk about dealing drugs, gun violence, and there are a couple of swear words here and there. The reader has to make a choice about the fate of the main character rather than being told what will happen. This was done intentionally by the author to make the reader decide. In an interview I watched with Jason Reynolds, he shared for the student reader he wants them to continue to reflect and be inquisitive, for the adult reader, the challenge is to reflect on potential biases and why a decision would be made.
f. VERDICT: I would have to say this would be a highly recommended read for high school aged students as it is a story about choices and consequences. A deliberate and open discussion about what happens throughout the story should be included to help students recognize and understand why choices were made and how new choices can be identified.
This has also been made into a graphic novel. You might want to check it out! I found it dark and more graphic (obviously) than the original, but very well done.
DeleteI agree with you that there should be a discussion incorporated into the use of this material, and I actually think it would be a discussion students would be eager to engage with. I think these themes are really ripe with tons of different directions to pull off on.
DeleteBeyond the ever after
ReplyDeleteby Jacqueline Woodson
a. & b. Audience
written for ages 10-13
appeal to ages 10-13
c. STRENGTHS:
This book written in verse focuses on a famous, revered athlete and his declining health through repeated concussions. It discusses his family members' view of him and the precious time spent with him when he is home which is something that the average teenager may relate to. The text shows the deterioration and the resulting slip into history with fans no longer seeking him while his family is dealing with the results of his years playing football and the injuries received causing CTE.
d. WEAKNESSES:
I feel that the text is a short read. If longer, there may have been more discussion of the thoughts and experiences of the family as he continues to struggle for years to come. While I know that is in the title, I think that it would have lead to more readers feeling the enormity of CTE and its long-lasting impact on families who care for these professional athletes long after they stop playing the game.
e. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
I feel as though there have been many athletes in the news with CTE predominantly considered as a cause for problems in society such as violence, suicide, and murder. I think that there may be instances brought up as a result of students seeking more information on their own.
f. VERDICT:
This book is a must have book in a middle school library as it is a topic of professional sports and the impacts of playing them. This may appeal to those playing sports and may be a springboard to reading other books written in verse.
I would recommend the Will Smith movie Concussion to read following this book. It is a great exploration of the same topic: https://youtu.be/Io6hPdC41RM
DeleteThe Crossover by Kwame Alexander
ReplyDeleteAudience: This novel is written for 5th through 8th graders.
Appeal: The fast pace and realistically portrayed themes that affect teens make this book appealing to middle and high school students, especially reluctant readers.
Strengths: The novel-in-verse format beautifully conveys basketball action, family dynamics, and the main character’s emotions. Cocky, flawed, sensitive Josh Bell couldn’t be more likable. The authentic portrayal of Josh’s feelings and experiences with his brother, parents, and as an athlete will resonate with students. Different fonts and text sizes are used creatively to add emphasis and interest to many poems. Several intertwined storylines unfold quickly, which keep the reader turning the pages. Complex words are highlighted with their own poems. This is an Own Voices book with a strong, close family.
Weaknesses: Some students unfamiliar with novels-in-verse may be reluctant to give the format a try. This book came out in 2014, so a few references seem a little dated.
Considerations: There are so many possibilities! This book could be used with a poetry unit. Students could create their poems in Alexander’s style using a sport or hobby they enjoy. Or they could use their own vocabulary words as inspiration for poetry. It would also be an excellent option for a book club with reluctant readers. The companion graphic novel could foster a great discussion about the different reading experiences. Booked and Rebound are two other books in The Crossover Series.
Verdict: This Own Voices book is an absolute must for all middle and high school libraries for its touching, relatable story and accessible, exciting poetry.
In my opinion, Booked is even more well written than The Crossover. Rebound is also very good but has heavier content and is not completely told in verse.
DeleteI know we discuss this often, but I cannot reiterate enough just how popular Kwame Alexander's books are with students in my school. His books reach a wide variety of readers and personalities, too, which is so wonderful as a media specialist. Seeing students connect over his books who do not normally connect is incredibly rewarding.
DeleteThe Crossover by Kwame Alexander
ReplyDeleteIntended Audience: Grade 5 - 8
Actual Audience: accurate
Strengths: This novel-in-verse acts as a doorway into this genre to those who may not otherwise ever dream of picking up a poetry collection. The verse format visually conveys the content. It contains strong own voice representation of a young Black boy. The main character, Joshua Bell, is well written so the reader empathizes with him as he faces challenges on and off the court. The relationships are believable and the action is gripping. The vocabulary used is overall at the appropriate reading level and when more advance terms are used they are often paired with a
Weaknesses: The format makes it difficult to decipher what is thought, what is speech, and what is descriptive. Pop culture references become dated quickly so the intended audience won’t be able to relate to some of the content long-term.
Special Considerations: A novel-in-verse about a topic that will appeal to young boys. This is the first novel in a series so could lead to further reading if a student enjoys it. Trigger warnings for this book include a sick parent and the death of a parent.
Verdict: This book should be included in middle school libraries and could also be included in high school libraries. With the strong own voice representation, relatable characters, and attention grabbing format, this novel-in-verse is an excellent choice for reluctant readers.
I think it can also be included in elementary libraries as long as it is recommended for older readers.
DeleteThe Crossover by Kwame Alexander
ReplyDeleteGr 5-7- This is a book based on a true fact about Josuah Bell and his twin brother Jordan (JB), whose father was a star for the Lakers in Los Angeles. Josh can't help but get in trouble and get punished by his school's principal, who is also his mother. The constant comparison between him and his brother annoys him, but all this changes when his father falls ill and dies of a heart attack. The strong parts of the book are the descriptions he makes of the characters that the twins admire, such as Michael Jordan or Barack Obama. Also emotional are the passages where Josh plays basketball and can't concentrate because of his problems at home. The book is written in verse and one can be complicit in Josh's jealousy when his brother JB finds a girlfriend. It is evident that he feels displaced and begins to do absurd things to get his attention. The chapters of the book are divided like the parts of a basketball game; Warm up, First quarter, Second quarter, Third quarter, Fourth quarter. I think maybe a downside of the book is that we don't hear as much of the father's voice in this story, and it would have been interesting to get his perspective a little bit. VERDICT I recommend this book for young people because is a Newbery Medal Winner, and it talks about the importance of having communication and keeping the family together despite all difficult circumstances. It is a work that moves with powerful language and great emotions about the loss of a loved one.
It also won the Coretta Scott King Honor Award.
DeleteThe One Thing You’d Save
ReplyDeleteLinda Sue Park
a & b) AUDIENCE & APPEAL This book is written for children in grades four through eight and appeals to the same range. High school students and adults who are curious about or appreciate poetry will find it compelling as well.
c) STRENGTHS Told through the voices of a teacher and her students, this book touches on many themes: diversity, inclusion, sentimentality, nostalgia, and more. It functions as poetry, realistic fiction, short story, and picture book. The nature of the book is diverse which strengthens the core theme of diversity in the text. The classroom comes to life through its deep conversation and holds readers’ interest from beginning to end.
d) WEAKNESSES Since narrators are not explicitly identified as they share their thoughts, readers may get confused as to who is saying what. The only way to tell when the teacher is speaking is by paying attention to the difference in font. Also, for those readers who crave a strong plot and story, this book does not include one; it is simply a conversation that takes place in a classroom, which may be a turn-off. It is important for them to understand, though, that this is not a novel but a form-poem bound by structure.
e) SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS Written in sijo (SHEE-jo), a form of Korean poetry from the 14th century, this book exposes readers to the magic of poetic form. Newbery medalist Park and debut illustrator Robert Sae-Heng combine their words and illustrations to create a thought-provoking and beautiful work of art.
f) VERDICT This book is an excellent choice for elementary and secondary libraries. At sixty-five pages with detailed black-and-white sketches, The One Thing You’d Save is a genre-defying, accessible text that readers at all levels will love.
You might have to do some pre-teaching before reading aloud so that students do pay attention to font and know who is speaking.
Delete
ReplyDeleteBooked by Kwame Alexander
a. Audience for whom the book is written: ages 11-13, grades 6-8
b. Audience to whom it will appeal: ages 10+, grades 5+; this book is an excellent avenue for getting reluctant readers of any age interested in reading. It is also a fresh, interesting take on a novel that will have voracious readers enthralled, as well.
c. Particular strengths of the book: This is Kwame Alexander’s follow up to his intensely popular book The Crossover. Booked is an excellently written soccer book, and good fiction books about soccer can be difficult to find. The novel-in-verse format, while not new, is particularly effective in attracting reluctant readers with its fresh, interesting format. Finishing a 314 page book in a relatively quick manner makes reading feel a lot less daunting. Further, the way Kwame Alexander plays with language, format, and form in his poems makes the book flow along in a lyrical and fluid way; each turn of the page is something new and exciting. There are modern pop culture references, as well as “classic” cultural references, that draw in the age group for which this book was written, making it a popular contemporary novel, and it is giving students cultural capital, which can make them feel like they belong. There is excellent vocabulary usage, exposing students to a range of unique and unconventional vocabulary words, like logorrhea or callipygous. The book deals with family dynamics that are important to discuss, such as the process of going through a divorce. It portrays adults in varied and dynamic ways; the relationship between him and his rapping librarian is heartwarming. There are so many ways in which this book can be incorporated into the classroom.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: Though the stories are rich enough without the sports focus, a student who does not like sports may not be eager to pick these books up, since the covers are so sports centered.
e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.): There is a graphic novel version of this book (and some of his others); the illustrator of these graphic novels is Dawud Anyabwile, a renowned and great artist. There are great curriculum links for Booked and other Kwame Alexander books: https://www.theclassroombookshelf.com/2016/05/booked/. The Crossover and his other books are very well-awarded, winning achievements like the Newbery Award and the Coretta Scott King Honor Award. Kwame Alexander has a lot of learning connections; there are plenty of videos and links on his website that support learning. He is a very active writer. This is an excellent book for offering representation for students of color.
f. Verdict: This book, along with the other books in this series, deserve a place on any library shelf where students grades 4 and up visit. The first person point of view, middle school romance, sports focus, modern pop culture references, and fresh voice makes this a must-read for readers, reluctant or voracious.
The Poet X by Elizabeth Acevedo
ReplyDeletea. Audience: grades 7 and up
b. Audience to whom it will appeal: middle school, high school, adult
c. Particular strengths of the book: Written in verse, own voice, Latinx, slam poetry, diversity, LGBTQIA+
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: There are many Catholic religious references that could turn students away or be completely confusing.
e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.): Many awards! Pura Belpre, National Book Award for Young People's Literature, Boston Globe-Horn Award for Fiction and Poetry, Golden Kite Award for Young Adult Fiction, and Carnegie Medal. YouTube videos are available of the author speaking about the book as well as audiobooks.
f. Verdict: This book deserves to be in middle school and high school libraries. It appeals to not only Latinx students, but any student that feels unheard or overshadowed by family expectations and drama.
The Crossover by Kwame Alexander
ReplyDeleteAudience: Grades 5-8
Appeal: Grades 5-12
Strengths: The novel is fast paced and includes high interest topics that can help engage reluctant readers. Readers will connect and relate to Josh.
Weaknesses: The Novel in verse style might be intimidating for some readers who haven't read a book in that style before. The plot also moves a little too quickly.
Special Considerations: The Crossover won the 2015 Newberry Medal and the Coretta Scott King Award Honor.
Verdict: This book should definitely be included in any middle school and high school library, as well as the two other books in the series.
Before the Ever After by Jacqueline Woodson
ReplyDeletea. Intended audience: Middle grades 3rd-8th grade
b. Audience appeal: 3rd grade and up
c. Strengths: Deals with the gradual loss of a loved one with grace and tenderness.
d. Weaknesses: If students were drawn to the book's sports connection, they may be disappointed as there is less sports content as the story progresses.
e. Special considerations: Winner of the Coretta Scott King Author award. Audiobook is a short 2 hour listen.
f. Verdict: This book is a great addition to any middle grades or young adult collection in need of additional novels in verse. This book is written by a BIPOC author and features diverse characters.