Please post on your choice of reading in this category. Remember, you are reading like a media specialist, so it is not about your personal likes and dislikes. Include in your post:
a. Audience for whom the book is written
b. Audience to whom it will appeal (might differ from a)
c. Particular strengths of the book
d. Particular weaknesses of the book
e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.)
f. And, in School Library Journal's format: your verdict supported with details
No plot summaries and no spoliers, please. Failure to follow that rule will result the revocation of your authoring rights, guaranteed!!!
My choice graphic novel was Heartstoppers Volume 1, because I have put more holds for this book, and followed up about when we were receiving more copies of this book than any other in our collection. I wanted to know why this book was so captivating to my students. The audience this book was written for is ages 12-17, or grades 6-12. I read the book in one night, and I believe any adult lovers of YA would enjoy the series as well. This book is the definition of charming, following the very sweet and supportive friendship and budding love between two rugby playing high school boys in England, Nick and Charlie. The art style is original, with unique panel shapes and even new speech styles where a tiny emoticon version of the character speaking is represented. Above all, the characters are endearing as they come. The book also depicts relationship violence, as Charlie’s ex-hookup engages in stalking, spamming and verbal and physical abuse. I think it is important for young adults to see the difference between harassment and love, and just because someone is actively pursuing you does not mean they care about your wellbeing. Lastly, as a strength, I think this book can be a bridge between lovers of online content and of physical books. Hearstoppers was originally published in installments as an online comic, and has that fandom following that taps into internet culture. The book does perhaps not offer too much complexity, the story is fairly predictable and there is limited character development. We don’t get to know the characters outside of their feelings for one another, and I believe as a queer person that there can be even deeper and more complex emotions related to discovering your own identity that I wish were explored a bit further. However, the simple story is well done and you cannot argue with the adorable illustrations. As we have seen with book challenges across the country, I wouldn’t be surprised if this book was difficult for certain parents whose religious beliefs interfere with LGBTQ+ identities. There is also language some might deem profane and mature themes related to relationship violence. I would just be aware that this book may be challenged when adding it to your collection. Hearstoppers is a must purchase for any teenage collection, casting a wide net to draw in reluctant readers and bibliophiles alike in an endearing and healthy depiction of teen love.
ReplyDeleteI think it is always a wise decision to pay attention to the books your students are reading and frequently checking out so that you can stay current with popular literature.
DeleteBook: Let’s Talk About It by Erika Moen and Matthew Nolan
ReplyDeleteIntended Audience: Grade 9 - 12 (age 14 - 17)
Actual Audience: whenever your school has deemed students attend sexual education lessons
Strengths: The artwork in this graphic novel does a phenomenal job at being inclusive in terms of gender, race, body types, and sexual orientation. It also does a good job at touching on a broad range of sexual education topics but doing it in a very non-intimidating way.
Weaknesses: Certain topics (ie pornography, sexting, STI’s) are spoken of too casually. These topics are important and could have very serious long-term ramifications for the students and therefore require more than a page or two of pictures with only a few lines of text.
Special Considerations: Having this book in general circulation could ultimately cause harm. However, used by a trained professional within the sexual education program and with supporting materials, this book provides an excellent ice breaker and introduction in easily understandable terms for a topic that is intrinsically awkward.
Verdict: This book is a must have for sexual education programs, but should be included in general circulation with extreme caution.
I agree, this book was incredibly inclusive in its illustrations and wholistic in its approach to sexuality in that it addressed gender, sexuality, consent, after care, etc. It is wise to consult with the teachers who are teaching sexuality to determine what resources are needed in your collection.
DeleteI survived the sinking of the Titanic
ReplyDeleteby Lauren Tarshis
a.& b. AUDIENCE:
Grades 3-7 in both written for and appeal.
c. STRENGTHS:
The graphic novel version of this text is a quick read with excellent illustrations. The story is very simple for lower ability readers and the text has more simplified vocabulary than the tradition text for this book.
d. WEAKNESSES:
The story is much shorter with some content missing to the facts of the story, which may leave holes for the reader of this text versus the reader of the traditional text.
e. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
There is a robber who does make threats to the boy in the book while he is down in the cargo area which may upset some children. Also, the sheer loss of lives on the Titanic, particularly those of lower financial means, may be upsetting to lower income students in the school.
f. VERDICT:
This book would be a great addition to an upper elementary library. There is a traditional short novel of the same concept, but this would offer options for a reluctant reader and/ or a reader who enjoys reading graphic novels.
Did you catch that they were floating on a debris that looked very similar to the movie at the end of the book? It seemed like a nod to the motion picture.
DeleteI did notice that as well. It reminded me of the movie in parts.
DeleteWhen Stars are Scattered
ReplyDeleteby Victoria Jamieson and Omar Mohamed
Audience & Appeal: The book was written for grades 5-8, but it appeals to a much larger audience as even adults would enjoy this book.
STRENGTHS: Omar is an incredibly strong and patient person. His story of waiting and hoping to find his mother and waiting and hoping to leave the refugee camp are touching and emotional. The images are well done and very detailed. A touching memoir that helps readers to understand life in a refugee camp and have empathy for people living in refugee camps for many years.
WEAKNESSES: Students who are a fan of Jamieson’s other books may be disappointed with this one because of its more serious nature.
CONSIDERATIONS: National Award Book Finalist; could connect to a unit on memoirs
VERDICT: Graphic novels are popular and a great way to introduce students to challenging topics or genres. This book is no different and would make an excellent addition to a library.
I love this book and agree it does a great job of introducing readers to life in a refugee camp. The resilience and courage of Omar and his brother are amazing.
DeleteIt also won a Schneider Family Book Award honor for its depiction of a character with a disability. It has been awarded and honored several other times and is a Maud Hart Lovelace nominee. Wikipedia has a list of awards. It's quite impressive! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/When_Stars_Are_Scattered
DeleteBad Sister by Charise Mericle Harper; illustrated by Rory Lucey
ReplyDeleteAudience: This graphic memoir is written for 3rd through 7th graders.
Appeal: The intended audience is accurate.
Strengths: The Sunday-comics style artwork has an appealing, retro feel. The author’s childhood struggles with her choices and emotions are effectively depicted and relatable to middle school students. The siblings’ old-school shenanigans make for an exciting adventure. In each chapter, the author examines how her behavior is linked to her feelings towards her brother Daniel and may inspire readers to do the same. The parents are both caring and flawed. This memoir is ultimately about power and forgiveness, which are significant themes that touch all families.
Weaknesses: Since this is an adult’s graphic memoir about a few years of her childhood, the perspective may be lost on middle school readers in the thick of that time of life.
Considerations: As a graphic memoir, this book could be paired with an art unit where students draw a scene from their own lives based on one of the chapters’ themes. The author has prosopagnosia (face blindness) so that could foster a discussion about cognitive disorders students may be unfamiliar with. A school counselor could use this book to initiate discussions about feelings and choices.
Verdict: Engaging artwork and a thoughtful examination of sibling rivalry, neighborhood adventure, forgiveness, and love make this graphic memoir a good addition to middle school libraries where graphic novels are popular.
You might pair this book with Guts by Raina Telgemeier which also explores social/emotional topics like anxiety in a graphic format.
DeleteGraphic Novel: Smile by Raina Telgemeier
ReplyDeletea. Audience for whom the book is written: Scholastic identifies grades 5-7 as the recommended audience for this title. Common Sense Media rates this book for ages 10+ by parents and 9+ by kids.
b. Audience to whom it will appeal: The recommended age for 10+ is appropriate. My daughter read this book when she was 8-9, but had better understanding of the content reading it this year, especially after she got braces herself.
c. Particular strengths of the book: The graphics and story work well together. The book describes some tricky topics including invasive dental work, some teasing/bullying from peers, an earthquake, and finding comfort in who a person is on the inside.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: I do not believe this story would be as appealing to young male students, there is a heavy focus on wanting to be liked by boys. There is also a scene where the main character's "friend" pulls down her skirt in front of other students as a joke.
e. Any special considerations: There are some references to growing up in the 80's as the author is recounting some experiences she had herself which made the book more appealing to me and I could share those nuances with my daughter. This book won the ALA's best and Notable Book Award.
f. VERDICT: I believe this is a "must have" addition to the elementary and middle school library. There are several graphic novels by the author Raina Telgemeier. Since the popularity of graphic novels has grown, I often am asked about books by this author when I am in the school library. Additional books include: Sisters, Drama, Guts, and Ghosts. There is character overlap for some of these books which might encourage students to read them all.
I can never keep Raina Telgemeier's books on the shelf. Here is a fun video you may want to share with your students" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5j3tiRUEqQ
DeleteGhosts by Raina Telgemeier
ReplyDeleteGr 4-8- Cat moves with her family to the north coast of California, since her sister Maya is very ill with cystic fibrosis. Life changes for both of them and they discover little by little with their neighbors and friends that this place is full of ghosts. Ghosts become more evident and take on importance on Halloween and Day of the Dead. Cat is skeptical of the change and traditions of the new place, but she discovers that it may not be a bad place to live. This book demonstrates the nostalgia for belonging to the Mexican culture and living in the United States. The book is divided into three parts, according to the month in which the characters live; September, October and the end of October. The strong points of the book are the cultural themes and when talking about a disease as drastic as cystic fibrosis. Another strong point is the design of the characters, the drawings of ghosts and the places with a Latin touch, such as the Mexican murals from the 60s and 70s that Cat and Maya find when they arrive in town. It also turns out to be an entertaining and fun graphic novel for young people. Some passages have few dialogues, they seem poorly developed sentences, which is why it is a point at a disadvantage to develop the story. VERDICT I recommend this book for young people since they will find different Mexican beliefs such as the Day of the Dead, and how the deceased visit their families, absorbing the essence of the food from the altars.
Have you read any other of Raina Telegemeier's books? I wondering how this one compares and which one you like best?
DeleteNew Kid by Jerry Craft
ReplyDeleteGr 4-7-Jordan is a 12-year-old and he hates the idea of being new to middle school so much that he draws pictures that look like total tragedy. This hobby becomes his passion as he wants to study at an art school. He wants to be like Batman to be able to face the bullying that other three boys (the three horse men of the Apocalypse) do to him and his best friend Ramón, of Nicaraguan origin, all the time at school. The strengths of this book is that it deals with the problems of bullying among students, gender confusion among young people, since Jordan and his team wear pink shirts to play soccer and make fun of them. We also find relevant references to festivities such as Kwanzaa, which is explained with appropriate drawings and descriptions.
I do not see any weakness in the book, on the contrary, it is highly recommended for young people and is a Winner of the 2020 Newbery Medal work. VERDICT this is a fun book for young people to understand their environment, their changes in adolescence with references to recognized movies such as Star Wars, Hunger Games and Fight Club. Also to understand that we should not judge people by their appearance because we are like books, you should not judge only by the cover.
This is an important book worth mentioning as it won the Newbery as a graphic novel. There is a companion novel which many fans have enjoyed called Class Act.
DeleteThey Called Us Enemy by George Takei
ReplyDeletea. Audience for whom the book is written: Common Sense Media says age 12+ (grades 6 and up)
b. Audience to whom it will appeal: grades 6 and up
c. Particular strengths of the book: Although it is a graphic novel, it is drawn in black and white. The shading and shadows are well done in order to portray emotion and action.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: I would have liked more color to show how desolate the internment camps were, but I feel the artist is using the black/white/gray to show the desolation.
e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.) About the author section, short historical recap of this time in history
f. Verdict supported with details: This book is a must have in any middle and high school media center as it appeals to the reluctant reader with vivid pictures as well as opening the door to a not so often talked about part of American history during World War II.
Great Expectations: The Graphic Novel by Charles Dickens, adapted by Brigit Viney
ReplyDeleteAudience for whom the book is written: ages 14-18, grades 9-12
Audience to whom it will appeal: ages 12+, grades 7+; any fan of Dickens would love to step into an illustrated version of one of his classics
Particular strengths of the book: The artwork and adaptation by Brigit Viney interpret well the complicated and comprehensive story written by Dickens. The illustrations are phenomenal, in full color, and add greatly to the retelling of this classic. The writing is easy to follow for young, contemporary readers. The characters are rich and full-bodied, making them interesting and true to the original. The first-person point of view, following Pip’s story from his perspective, also rings true to Dickens’s work and draws the reader into the plot in a more intimate way. The story is complex, riveting, and offers great insight into early Victorian England.
Particular weaknesses of the book: Great Expectations is a long and complicated story, which means that adapting it to a more contemporary and simple form is a hard task. While Viney did a great job, there were points in the story that seemed a little too simplified; there were some plot jumps that were abrupt or confusing.
Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.): This would be an excellent addition to a classroom unit on Great Expectations; it would allow young readers to “see” the time, follow the action visually, and better comprehend the story. It would be particularly great for English language learners, reluctant readers, students with learning challenges, etc., allowing all students the cultural capital that comes from reading classic literature. There is a list of characters with names at the beginning, more complete character summaries at the end, a comprehensive glossary, a brief biography on Charles Dickens, a page on the historical context of Great Expectations, a note on the two endings that were written by Dickens, and important quotations from Dickens’s story with explanations as to why they are important.
Verdict: Great Expectations: The Graphic Novel adapted by Brigit Viney is a must-have in library collections and classrooms that service students in grades 9-12; this graphic novel version of a literary classic brings Pip’s story to life in an accessible and beautiful way, doing justice to Dickens’s legacy.
Turtle in Paradise
ReplyDeleteJennifer L. Holm.
a & b) AUDIENCE & APPEAL This graphic novel was written for grades 3 through 8 and appeals to the same audience.
c) STRENGTHS This is a graphic novel written in the historical fiction genre. The story is compelling, and the characters are realistic and entertaining, especially the main character Turtle who is intelligent, clever, and sweet. Additionally, the setting is historically accurate, and the intentional color choices and detailed panels bring the 1930s Florida Keys landscape and living conditions to life.
d) WEAKNESSES There are a lot of characters to keep track of in this graphic novel, but having images of the characters helps immensely. The resolution moves very quickly, and the ending is abrupt, which may leave readers with too many unanswered questions.
e) SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS At the end of the novel, there is an author’s note that includes historical facts along with information about how the artist designed the book. This particular graphic novel was created with the work of an illustrator and a colorist, which explains the gorgeous use of color on every page.
f) VERDICT This graphic novel is a must have in a middle school library collection. Students who enjoy historical fiction or other Jennifer L. Holm books will love this.
My Hero Academia by Kohei Horikoshi
ReplyDeleteAudience: Ages 14 to adults
Appeal: Ages 11 to adults
Strength: MHA is an incredibly popular manga/anime series, and it is a great way to engage reluctant readers. The illustrations are very well done and helps with reading comprehension. Izuku is a very kindhearted protagonist, and he is surrounded by a bevy of quirky characters, each with their own unique personality and background story.
Weakness: There is occasional swearing and female characters are often drawn in more suggestive poses.
Special Considerations: This manga was originally released July 7, 2014, in Japan.
Verdict: My Hero Academia is a must have for your middle school/ high school manga section. It is a great blend of comedy, action, and positive messages that many young readers will connect with.
This is THE Manga title that I am hearing everyone rave about!
Deletea. Intended audience: 4th-8th grade
ReplyDeleteb. Audience appeal: 4th grade and up
c. Strengths: This was the first graphic novel I ever liked. The story, the characters, illustration, and history are so well done.
d. Weaknesses: I can't think of any
e. Special considerations: Winner of the Sydney Taylor Award, which is outstanding books that authentically portray the Jewish experience for children and teens.
f. Verdict: This book should be in every library that serves middle grade and young adult readers. A stunning graphic novel that weaves a story of the holocaust. Loosely connected to the Wonder books by R.J. Palacio.