Please post on your choice of reading in this category. Remember, you are reading like a media specialist, so it is not about your personal likes and dislikes. Include in your post:
a. Audience for whom the book is written
b. Audience to whom it will appeal (might differ from a)
c. Particular strengths of the book
d. Particular weaknesses of the book
e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.)
f. And, in School Library Journal's format: your verdict supported with details
No plot summaries and no spoliers, please. Failure to follow that rule will result the revocation of your authoring rights, guaranteed!!!
Book Title: Shadow and Bone by Leigh Bardugo
ReplyDeleteI wanted to challenge myself to dive into a true fantasy read after having some aversion to the genre for whatever reason growing up. I chose Shadow and Bone by Leigh Bardugo because of its popularity, and my students' interest in the Netflix series. The intended audience of this book is readers ages 12-18 or grades 7-12. I believe this book would interest high school and young adult readers, as well as fantasy lovers of all ages. The book does a very thorough job of world building, and presents a unique context for the plot that brings up deep issues such as class, war, empowerment and belonging. I think any sort of book series that has room for fandom is a big draw for students, and I believe this trilogy absolutely checks that box and promotes further engagement with reading. I do think that for a middle school audience, this book may lose readers because of its high reading level that requires deep comprehension to follow the world building done in the first half of the book. There are many different titles, locations, verbs and roles in the society that are words that would be unfamiliar to students and hard to keep track of. I worry that for that reason many would give up on this book before it presents the plot twists that pull you in for the long run. http://www.mackidsschoolandlibrary.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/ShadowAndBoneTeachersGuide_Final.pdf
I found this link to have a lot of great curriculum resources to accompany the read. It asks readers to engage with the questions of moral code that the book brings up. There is a lot of ambiguity when it comes to doing the right thing, particularly when you are in a period of personal development and still learning so much about the world, and I think it would be a strong practice for students to consider what they think about the choices Alina makes in the novel. A fantasy read rich with world building and intense turning points, and all the battle scenes, magic powers and romance you'd hope to find, Shadow and Bone is a must purchase for high school libraries. For middle grade libraries, this book is a purchase-if-the-genre-needs-updating due to way the reading level leans towards older readers.
Here is the official Netflix Trailer: https://youtu.be/b1WHQTbJ7vE
DeleteI am glad that you chose to dip your toes into the fantasy genre with Leigh Bardugo. I think she is a pretty wonderful, fresh, and powerful author in her area of expertise. Shadow and Bone is definitely a popular title with YA fantasy readers. I also really loved the Netflix adaptation!
Deletea. Audience for whom the book is written: Grades 4-7
ReplyDeleteb. Audience to whom it will appeal: Grades 5 and up
c. Particular strengths of the book: This story is 217 pages long and moves along fairly quickly. The characters connect with one another well. There is a nice push pull between two brothers, the younger brother wants to help and support the older brother and their relationship grows throughout the book. There is a police officer who recognizes the need to just be present and listen to Aidan even when his story seems unbelievable.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: Aidan tells a story of where he has been for six days while he has been missing. He describes a new place and there could have been a lot more time spent on that, I think that would appeal to younger readers a great deal.
e. Any special considerations: In the end the reader is left to decide what they think happened and this could be difficult for younger readers who may want a more concrete ending. The adults do not believe Aidan and struggle to support him at times.
f. Verdict: This book is a middle school must have for readers who love fantasy, conflict, and have a strong imagination. I would not recommend this book for elementary readers as the ending is not concrete and there is a lot of room for inference and drawing one's own conclusion.
Beth, what book is this for?
DeleteOh shoot! The book was
DeleteThe Mysterious Disappearance of Aidan S. ( Told by his brother) by David Levithan
It turns out David Levithan has written several books. Check them out here: http://www.davidlevithan.com/category/books/
DeleteWow several familiar titles! Thanks Dr. Hill.
DeleteBook: Legendborn by Tracy Deonn
ReplyDeleteIntended Audience: Grade 9 - 12 (age 14+)
Actual Audience: YA - Adult
Strengths: Strong world-building and storytelling weaves together the myth and magic of the Arthurian legend with the modern-day real world setting of a high school senior attending on-campus PSEO classes. The female lead is tenacious and determined despite the emotional turmoil she is suffering through due to the loss of her mother just prior to the beginning of the book. It is written with an authentic voice of a Black woman growing up in the south. There is also other minority representation amongst the first level of secondary characters including Asian-American and gender nonconforming characters.
Weaknesses: This book is about 500 pages so it will be intimidating to some readers but a welcome challenge to the bookworms of the school.
Special Considerations: This is the first book of a series and will be a great hook for readers who enjoy deep diving into a fantasy world. With the ties to King Arthur, this book could be used as a very modern take on the Arthurian literature. It could also be given to students who are struggling with loss as grief and coping with grief are a strong theme within the story and those emotions are sometimes easier to process from within a fantastical world. Trigger warnings for this book include death of a parent, racism, and the implication of rape.
Verdict: This book is a must have in high school libraries because it has strong own voice representation of a Black female but the themes and world-building are maybe too advance for the younger end of YA.
I am curious, do you enjoy long books because of their opportunity to provide details?
DeleteI have been so tempted to buy this one for our library, but I hesitate because it is so long. They are a tough sell for busy students especially during the school year.
DeleteChildren of Blood and Bone
ReplyDeleteby Tomi Adeyemi
a & b: AUDIENCE AND APPEAL Gr 10-12, appeals to high school and adults
c. STRENGTHS Each chapter is written from each main characters point of view. Nigerian folklore woven into the story.
d. WEAKNESSES Secondary characters are brought into the plot without much background shared with the reader and leaves the reader confused about the character's future in the story. Also uses possible authentic place and god's names which can be confusing at times.
e. CURRICULUM LINKS This book would work well in a diversity literature circle of books from around the world.
f. VERDICT This book is a must-have for secondary libraries. It brings diverse stories and folklore to students and it is also a great active adventure for fantasy book lovers!
Jimmy Fallon interviewed the author: https://youtu.be/6dp8BcJuGnQ
DeleteTitle: Dead Wednesday
ReplyDeleteAuthor: Jerry Spinelli
a.& b. AUDIENCE:
Written for grades 5-6
Appeal to: middle school and young adult
c. STRENGTHS:
-takes a tough topic of preventable deaths of teenagers and
gives the perspective of one who passed through the perspective
of the ghost
-shows the transformational thought of the main character a
throughout the story as he spends time with the ghost
d. WEAKNESSES:
-unclear as to how or why the ghost appeared which can be
confusing in that part of the story for the reader
-discusses how it changed him forever, but does not give enough
evidence of that which makes the end of the book seem abrupt
in its ending.
e. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
-references some preventable types of death of teenagers which
may be important to brainstorm ideas as to what that may
include with students before reading so as to get the magnitude
of choices as the death of the ghost character may not be one
that students can connect to other serious ways (texting and
driving, drinking, etc.)
f. VERDICT:
It is a must have for the middle school library as it is a
fluid read that will maintain the interest of students while
teaching them the importance of our choices that can become
serious.
Although I personally did not enjoy this book, I agree that it does have a place in the middle/high school library. I thought the main character was a realistic middle school student who made a lot of growth by the end of the story and had learned to accept himself. The message that Spinelli was trying to convey with the dead teenagers about how choices teens make can cause permanent consequences is an important one for students to reflect on.
DeleteIt's okay that this book was not liked. Sometimes we have to recommend books we'd never personally want to read. Perhaps you could introduce your students to Jerry Spinelli's They Library Card or Maniac McGee instead!
DeleteThe Beatryce Prophecy
ReplyDeleteby Kate DiCamillo
Audience & Appeal: The book is written for 3rd-6th grade students. Although I normally think Kate DiCamillo’s books have a larger audience this one was more predictable and may not appeal to older readers.
STRENGTHS: I love Kate DiCamillo’s personification of animals and the goat in this book is no different. It was a nice story of friendship, although I did not root for Beatryce as much as I would have expected. I like Brother Edik and Jack Dory’s characters and enjoyed the prophecy of a girl who would unseat the king and bring great change, although I was not surprised by any of the events. I’m always fascinated by authors who weave different characters and their storylines together.
WEAKNESSES: It seemed a bit predictable- it's called the Beatryce Prophecy and there’s a prophecy about a girl unseating the king and bringing change.
CONSIDERATIONS: The story is set in the middle ages so if students were studying that time period this book would connect well. Also, studying the writing and word choice in the book- there are some well written phrases and interesting vocabulary that students could learn.
VERDICT: I would add it because I think DiCamillo is a popular author and the book isn’t too long to be overwhelming to students. There are also some great illustrations in the book.
This is a longer interview, but here Kate DiCamillo talks about The Beatryce Prophecy: https://www.mprnews.org/episode/2021/10/04/talking-volumes-kate-dicamillo
DeleteI really loved this book. I think it was the language that drew me in. I agree that it may not have great appeal with middle schoolers though.
DeleteAru Shahand and the End of Time
ReplyDeleteby Roshani Chokski
Gr 4-6-One day, Aru, an 11-year-old girl, walks through the rooms of her mother's work, the Museum of Art and Culture of Ancient India. Three friends go to make fun of her for not traveling in summer and lying to them about it. But for a prank, they light a magic lamp (Bharata) and wake up the Lord of Destruction. Her mother and her friends are frozen, and Aru must travel to another dimension with her guardian, a little dove, and Mini, another girl, to save the world.
On her journey, Aru discovers that she and Mini are demi-goddesses (padava). They leave Atlanta to search for the keys to the Kingdom of Death, traversing deserts, wintry spaces, and quicksand. Strengths of the book are the descriptions of the places and the stories of the Hindu gods she encounters such as Shukra (wealth), Indra (thunder) and Yama (god of death).
The only downside of this book is that with so many Hindu names, the reader can get lost in the plot, so you have to go to the Glossary at the end of the book and check it out. References to Hindu culture such as clothing, sculptures and handicrafts are accurately and beautifully described. An example is the weapons that Aru finds like the headband with powers and her bow with an arrow. VERDICT is a worthwhile book for youngsters, inviting reading as it features hilarious and humorous adventures on Aru's part as she speaks with the gods on each perilous journey.
There are more resources here including an educator's guide: https://www.roshanichokshi.com/books/aru-shah-and-the-end-of-time/
DeleteThe Lion of Mars
ReplyDeleteby Jennifer L. Holm
Gr 4-6-Bell is an 11-year-old boy who lives on Mars with other children in the year 2091. They don't know Earth and therefore spend their time studying the humans who live on it. Unfortunately, the people in his group on Mars start to get sick from a virus and the children try to ask for help and medicine from Earth. Bell does not hesitate to break the rules and is injured in the shoulder on a journey outside in the craters of the planet Mars. Bell will recover the symbol of the lion (strength, courage, wisdom) since he must gather strength to recover physically, help his friends and heal the void left by the death of his best friend, farmer Phineus.
Bell's childhood and adolescence is spent between Charleston dances, light-blocking storms, killer plants and repeating the moonwalk like Michael Jackson. In terms of format, it is different from other books, since the chapters are introduced with Via secure communication messages, between CDR Dexter (the Mars group) and the US Terrestrial Command. VERDICT This work has no weaknesses, it is a significant book that every teenager should read, and you can find excellent descriptions of the mountains and craters of Mars, the two satellites, and scientific terms about microalgae and hydration. As the reading progresses you can feel the tension and vulnerability of the characters as they run out of oxygen and even encounter alien beings.
I mentioned tonight in class that Jennifer L Holm has written quite a bit. Here is a link to her site: https://www.jenniferholm.com/babymouse-graphic-novels
DeleteShadow and Bone by Leigh Bardugo
ReplyDeletea. Audience for whom the book is written: ages 12-18, grades 7-12
b. Audience to whom it will appeal: ages 12+, grades 7+ (This is one I think would appeal to fans of fantasy of any age.)
c. Particular strengths of the book: Leigh Bardugo’s writing style is fresh and instantly captivating. There is a movement to her writing that draws the reader in and carries them from chapter to chapter. This is a world-building novel, and the Grishaverse is developed fully and well, incorporating elements of magic, Russian and Slavic folklore, and more. The author does a good job of genuinely surprising the reader; whereas some YA fantasy authors rely on tropes to substantiate their stories, Bardugo breaks and bends these tropes to create a story that feels genuine and original. There is a strong female protagonist whose personality and history are fully developed, relatable, and human. All of the main characters are well-developed and likable in their own way. This story questions and talks about discrimination, power, good and evil, love, greed, honesty, and more, making it an excellent avenue to think critically about our reality but through a lens that is less threatening and immediate.
d. Particular weaknesses of the book: The reading level of this book may be a challenge for some young readers. In general, it is hard for me to identify many weaknesses of this book. It may be worth noting that the Russian influences may be poignant at this time as current events between Russia and Ukraine escalate; it may, however, be a good discussion point.
e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.): The story includes some elements of Tsarist Russian and Slavic cultures. It also focuses on the historically magical perception of science and alchemy. It is well-reviewed by other well-known YA authors, like Sarah J. Mass and Rick Riordan. It is book one of the Shadow and Bone trilogy, which has other spin off series (like the King of Scars series and Six of Crows series) all taking place in the Grishaverse; this offers an opportunity to keep readers coming back to books, allowing them to be part of a larger conversation. Leigh Bardugo has several other titles too, so if students like her writing, they will be able to move across genres and storylines. Shadow and Bone has brought the Grishaverse to life as a series on Netflix. It is well reviewed in general, and it has Common Core connections, lesson plan ideas, and more, found here from the publisher’s website: https://static.macmillan.com/static/macmillan/2020-online-resources/downloads/shadow-and-bone-trilogy-common-core-guide.pdf
f. Verdict: Shadow and Bone by Leigh Bardugo is a must-have title in any library collection that services young adults (and above)--it is a fresh take on YA fantasy with a strong, capable female protagonist; with opportunity for Common Core curricular connections and discussions on important universal themes; and with a large fandom that will keep readers coming back for the other books in Bardugo’s Grishaverse world.
(Here is a link to the "Grishaverse" website that has lots of fun information and educator resources: https://grishaverse.com/)
Here is the official Netflix Trailer: https://youtu.be/b1WHQTbJ7vE
DeleteAmari and the Night Brothers by B.B. Alston
ReplyDeleteAudience: This novel is written for 3rd through 6th graders.
Appeal: The target audience is accurate, but this book will entertain fantasy lovers of any age.
Strengths: The first book of a planned trilogy offers creative world building and unique adventure, but what sets it apart is its coverage of bias and profiling regarding race and a person’s magical ability. Main character Amari is brave and loyal with a feistiness that is balanced by humility. The familiar theme of belonging feels fresh in a supernatural world that will be new to readers but grounded with several characters from traditional fantasy. Although the book covers weighty topics, it doesn’t take itself too seriously and cleverly uses laugh-out-loud humor with nods to current technology and popular culture.
Weaknesses: A betrayal at the end felt inconsistent with the character’s personality up to that point. The juvenile but adorable artwork on the cover could deter upper middle grade and high school readers.
Considerations: This book offers a way to discuss racism through a feature that humans (as far as I know) do not possess: magical ability. Students may feel more open and comfortable talking about prejudice and bias without some class members feeling like they are in the spotlight or need to speak for a certain diversity. This book won the Overall Award for Barnes & Noble’s inaugural Children’s and YA Book Awards.
Verdict: This book is highly recommended for middle school libraries for the fun, original way the author pairs a fantastical adventure with the serious and relevant topics of race, bias, prejudice, and power.
Looks like the next one comes out on August 30th: https://www.harpercollins.com/products/amari-and-the-great-game-b-b-alston?variant=39379741245474
DeleteBeasts and Beauty: Dangerous Tales
ReplyDeleteSoman Chainani
a & b) AUDIENCE & APPEAL This collection of fairy tales is written for grades five through eight. This chilling, magnificent work appeals to students in this grade range along with older students in high school and beyond.
c) STRENGTHS. Dark like the Brothers Grimm but still bright and full of hope, this book is a gallery of beautiful stories and beautiful images not meant for the faint of heart. These tales cover themes like vanity, love, family, brotherhood, forgiveness, growing up, and more. It is inclusive of a wide variety of cultures, the LGBTQIA+ community, women, the elderly, underprivileged communities, and outcasts.
d) WEAKNESSES Although some stories have satisfying endings that are tied in a bow, some stories have ambiguous endings that leave readers with too many questions. Additionally, the dialogue is difficult to follow at times because quotation marks are not used during conversations.
e) SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS - ILLUSTRATIONS Detailed black-and-white sketches can be found on most of the pages, but a colored illustration signifies to readers that the particular story has come to an end. Although this can be read out of order, there are hints in each tale of what the subsequent story may be which is fun, engaging, and strengthens its quality as a page-turner.
f) VERDICT This book is a must-have in middle school and high school libraries. People across ages will enjoy enchanting twists on stories they grew up with to make new meanings and learn new lessons.
I love that this book can introduce the reader to so many fairy tales! I think this may pair well with Marissa Meyer's books: https://www.universeofmarissameyer.com/books/cinder/
DeleteI loved these types of fairy tale retellings as a kid, but it feels like this author really took the opportunity to take this trope to the next level with tackling richer themes and more diverse voices. I'm really looking forward to checking it out, thanks for the review.
DeleteBook: Dragonwatch by Brandon Mull
ReplyDeletea.Intended audience: Grades 5-9
b.Recommended Audience: Grades 5-12
c.It’s a simple read and it tells a story for multiple viewpoints, but Seth and Kendra’s. It addresses simple examples of depression, acceptance and taking responsibility, while keeping a light and fun view on the world. It shows great storytelling and doesn't contain to many "slow parts" which help keep readers involved.
d.There is a lack of representation, but besides the two main characters there are only a handful of human characters, most of whom are family members.
e.Strong family values and sibling relationship.
f.This is a must have fantasy read with its cousin series Fablehaven. It shows off how the magical world can exist in our world still and how even the most “boring and uptight” people can have a purpose in the magical world.
It looks like an educator's guide is available on the author's website: http://brandonmull.com/educators/
DeleteBooks: The whole series is so good, I couldn't pick just one.
ReplyDeleteSerafina & the Black Cloak (#1)
Serafina and the Twisted Staff (#2)
Serafina & the Splintered Heart (#3)
Serafina & the Seven Stars (#4)
a & b) AUDIENCE & APPEAL: From a conversation, author event I know that they were intended for readers in 4th-8th grade. Can be enjoyed by and appeals to any reader age 10+
c) STRENGTHS - Incredible descriptive writing. Great mentor text for painting a scene through words. Only book series set at Biltmore estate endorsed by the Vanderbilt family. Combines elements of historical fiction, American folklore, and fantasy elements. Feels like an American answer to Harry Potter with a female protagonist.
d) WEAKNESSES - the rich vocabulary could be challenging for some students.
e) SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS - The books are very spooky and some younger readers might find them too scary.
f) VERDICT - I think that Serafina belongs in every library that serves grades 4 and up. I have seen so many kids fall in love with fantasy after reading this in class.
For those who are unfamiliar with the series, more information can be found here: https://robertbeattybooks.com/books/serafina-and-the-black-cloak/
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteBook: Red Queen by Victoria Aveyard
ReplyDeleteAudience: Grades 9-12
Appeal: Grades 7-12
Strengths: The worldbuilding in this series is super interesting. The setting takes place in a future dystopian version of the United States, and it is very fun to try and identify locations in the story with its real-life locations.
Weaknesses: The protagonist occasionally makes very selfish and immature choices which makes it difficult to root for her at times. The story also uses a fair amount of cliches that are found in other dystopian YA novels. (Love triangles, leading a rebellion against an oppressive government, etc.)
Special Considerations: There is a good amount of violence and death in this series which might be scary or upsetting to younger readers.
Verdict: This book is definitely a must have for a YA library! I had to read the entire series to find out what happens at the end.