Non-Fiction

  Please post on your choice of reading in this category.  Remember, you are reading like a media specialist, so it is not about your personal likes and dislikes. Include in your post:

a. Audience for whom the book is written

b. Audience to whom it will appeal (might differ from a)

c. Particular strengths of the book

d. Particular weaknesses of the book

e. Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.)

f. And, in School Library Journal's format: your verdict supported with details

No plot summaries and no spoliers, please.  Failure to follow that rule will result the revocation of your authoring rights, guaranteed!!!

24 comments:

  1. Everything you Wanted to Know about Indians but were Afraid to Ask by Anton Treuer

    a. Audience for whom the book is written: There are two versions of this book, one for adult readers and one that is a young readers edition. The young readers edition is recommended for ages 12-18 by Kirkus and Grades 5-8 by Title Wave.

    b. Audience to whom it will appeal: This book would appeal to ages 12 and up and is just as informative as the adult version, even though it is written for students.

    c. Particular strengths of the book: The book begins with a detailed table of contents if a student has a particular question, they could easily locate the right section of the book and go to the section to read the response of the author. The author grew up in and around Leech Lake Reservation. This book includes information that could expand any middle schooler's education. The author provides recommendations for additional reading a the end of the book as well.

    d. Particular weaknesses of the book: Although this book is written well so the reader moves through each section with ease, it is not a single story with a finite list of characters. There is a lot of history and facts included by the author who self identifies as sharing his experiences and not speaking for all Native experiences.

    e. Any special considerations The book includes numerous pictures from history with explanations about the validity or lack thereof.

    f. VERDICT: This book is a must have for a school library, social studies or english class. Students who read this book would be awarded with an expanded view of others and would likely have many myths about the Native community debunked.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would also recommend Indian No More: https://www.leeandlow.com/books/indian-no-more

      Delete
  2. Fallout: Spies, Superbombs, and the Ultimate Cold War Showdown by Steve Sheinkin

    Audience: This novel is written for 5th through 8th graders.

    Appeal: The Cold War was a complex time in history, so engaging the average 5th or 6th grader may be a stretch. This book definitely would appeal to upper-middle grade through adults.

    Strengths: Sheinkin does a fantastic job laying out the events leading to the Cuban Missile Crisis by featuring world leaders, military and political players, scientists, spies, and the lives of everyday citizens. Short chapters with catchy titles like “We Will Bury You” and “The Headless Spy” keep the pace moving while breaking up key developments and events into smaller pieces. The personal weight Khruschov and Kennedy felt with the fate of the human race in their hands is evident. Photographs at the beginning of each of the three parts help readers keep track of key players.

    Weaknesses: A timeline would have been helpful to put significant events into chronological perspective.

    Considerations: Photographs of bunker drills, actual fallout shelters, East German citizens dropping out of windows into West Berlin, and Cuban rebel fighters are presented throughout the book. Further discussion and study show students how events on the world stage during the Cold War affected the lives of regular people. This book would pair well with a traditional social studies unit of the same period.

    Verdict: This fascinating book is essential to middle and high school libraries for its detailed, clear coverage of the Cold War and its impact on the lives of well-known leaders, obscure players, and average citizens.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would also recommend his previous book, The Bomb, which won several awards: http://stevesheinkin.com/books/

      Delete
  3. The choice book that I read for the non-fiction genre was Born A Crime: Adapted for Young Readers by Trevor Noah. According to Titlewave, the young readers edition appeals to readers in grades 5-8, a true middle grade title. Having read both versions of this text, I did not notice a huge difference in content and reading level. Many reviews note that the original version of the text would interest YA audiences, especially grades 11-12. I agree, and believe that both versions would appeal to readers ages 14+. The strengths of the book are the educational content. Noah breaks down the complexities and nuances of life under Aphartheid in South Africa brilliantly. He demonstrates just how almost comical it can be to critically evaluate a system built without solid grounds. He helps readers to understand systematic racism, oppression, slavery, law and language. On top of this, it is filled with humor, heart and an incredible wow factor when it comes to the story of Noah’s mother Patricia Nombuyiselo Noah and the spirit and strength that was never given to her, but grown inside herself. The weaknesses of the book is that although brief and well explained, there is a lot of (necessary) informational content, and some young readers may be uninterested in this style of book when reading for pleasure. On top of this, the book is a bit disjointed. The chapters are as if they were written without a particular order in mind, as the narrative often circles back and explains a period of Noah’s life that was already laid out in detail, or jumps around in time to the point it can be difficult to ground yourself in the narrative. This would be a wonderful text to accompany a unit on Aphartheid, racism or world voices. Readers from the US might have had little exposure to a South African perspective, and Noah’s account is vivid and comedic. It is also notable that Trevor Noah has tons of critical content that young adults may already know and love from his career as a comedian, which could be a thread followed throughout the year. This piece of creative nonfiction is original, vibrant and captures a variety of crucially important themes and pieces of history. It is a must purchase for any library serving young adults.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have the adult version but have not read it yet. I was surprised how text heavy it was and if readers were unaware of Aphartheid, they would have some studying to do in order to grasp the context.

      Delete
  4. Stamped: Racism, Anti-Racism, and You
    by Jason Reynolds and Ibram X. Kendi

    a.& b. AUDIENCE:
    -written for: grades 7 and up
    -appeals to: grades 6 and up

    c. STRENGTHS:
    -voice of authors woven throughout book
    -simplifies the original text and makes it easy to follow for
    young adults
    -infuses emphasis on important points through repetitive text
    -uses humor in appropriate ways to give deeper meaning to some
    concepts

    d. WEAKNESSES:
    -really are no weaknesses

    e. SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS:
    -terms and phrases used in the history of racism that may be
    disturbing to some students

    f. VERDICT:
    I feel this is a must have for any middle school and high school library. It gives the introduction to how racism has existed in our country as well as how it has been represented and continues to be to this day. It is great representation of a "non-history" history book as Reynolds and Kendi write in the text. It is a well done shorted version of the longer, more intense original adult version of the text.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with your verdict, the humor and contemporary language make the story pop off the page in comparison to many informational/non fiction texts. It also builds a really big picture of how racism is embedded into our country's history, while remaining a simple and short text to read.

      Delete
    2. I learned so much from this book and agree it is so well done. I'm surprised that it's been challenged so often.

      Delete
    3. This book explains its concepts well. I would also pair it with Revolution in Our Time by Kekla Magoon which was also on our reading list this semester.

      Delete
  5. How We Got to the Moon
    By John Rocco

    Gr-5-6-Realistic fiction book, divided in seven parts. The beginning shows the emergence of rockets and projects of NASA to reach the Moon. Likewise, the designs of a crocket are explained with drawings, how they made it fly, Newton's laws and original photos of the physicists, geologists, scientists, involved in each mission. In each chapter experiments are presented with drawings explaining each process of physics. There are also problems that were raised at NASA such as the issue of fuel, food packaging, and survival training if a problem arose when returning to Earth. Each of these hypotheses are presented how they are solved. Particular strengths of the book are the explanations of the preparation process, during and after reaching the satellite and when the first man walked on it on July 21, 1969. A disadvantage of this book is that it is very long, but it is understandable since many years of preparation take place before man could travel to the Moon. Special considerations are the high quality of the drawings, the photo at the end of the book, in which the author appears in an astronaut suit, mentions the places he visited to write this book such as NASA, recommends other works on this topic, and commonly used acronyms during Apollo. VERDICT it is a good book since we can find all the Apollo missions, from number 7 to 17, the great challenges that these physicists faced to get to the Moon, from sending animals as tests, the Mercury project to train those who would travel and the description of the design of the special suit they used on the Moon is surprising.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I LOVED this book! It was so well done. I agree it is long. It's the type of book that you pick up and put down from time to time as you read each section. I would recommend pairing with Astronauts: Women of the Final Frontier: https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781626728776/astronauts

      Delete
    2. This was one of my absolute favorites from the Children's Literature class I took last summer. I added it to my personal "to buy" list, because of the beautiful imagery and because I was so in awe at how much interesting, comprehensive information there was. In fact, I felt I had to buy it because I had checked it out from my local library but found it was too long for me to finish before I had to return it! Excellent analysis, Karina!

      Delete
  6. Gone to the Woods: Surviving a Lost Childhood
    by Gary Paulsen

    Audience & Appeal: Titlewave has the interest level at 3rd-6th grade. I think the book would appeal more to older readers, probably 6th grade to adult readers.

    STRENGTHS: I was never a huge fan of Gary Paulsen’s books but this book made me fall in love with his story. The book does a good job of cutting down 80 years of Paulsen’s life into a manageable length, and mostly keeps the story moving. The events are incredibly interesting, and Paulsen’s discovery of the library and the kind librarian who helped him fall in love with reading and start writing was so touching.

    WEAKNESSES: For a book at the 3rd-6th grade interest level, there are parts of the book that would not be age appropriate (prostitution, neglect, war, and death). As an adult reader I would’ve preferred a bit more of his adult life in the story, but the story was focused on his difficult childhood.

    VERDICT: This book would make an excellent addition to a middle school or high school library, particularly as students are likely familiar with Gary Paulsen.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You can find out more about how a library card changed his life here: http://read420authorstudies.blogspot.com/2007/11/gary-paulsen.html
      I wanted to add this book to the list this semester since Gary Paulsen recently passed and many are familiar with this Minnesotan's work.

      Delete
  7. I added this book to our collection but haven't had a chance to read it yet. I've been curious about his story so glad to hear you recommend it!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Picturing a Nation
    The Great Depression’s Finest Photographers Introduces America to Itself
    By Martin W. Sandler

    Gr 11-adult-This is a photo book during the Great Depression in the United States. It not only shows the financial problems, it also shows the problems on the farms. The author mentions that the purpose of collecting these 140 photos was to show the things that have been corrected and appreciated during this crisis. The work is composed of seven chapters that highlight the different areas of the country and reflect what was happening with society at that time. These are photos that the author, Martin W. Sandler, recovered from 10 photographers and some people who were not professionals but who dedicatedly portrayed the times with just a simple Kodak camera. Negatives of these photos were a permanent part of the Library of Congress until 1944. I don't find weak points in this work, just maybe I would like them to add more photographs of the cities, that cosmopolitan side that was also affected. The strong points are the classification by areas of the country in which we appreciate photos of the Midwest, South, The West, and Northeast. A relevant point is that the African American culture is perceived in the chapter on the South and the segregation suffered by 3 million African Americans. The chasm between the photos of cotton plantations with barefoot African Americans and the photos of white people at festivals in Louisiana and others at parties in Miami is visible. VERDICT This book is worth in any library because it also includes source notes, bibliography, photo credits, and an index. Seems to me to be a relevant book to understand the Great Depression from the photos that are moving and sad in the face of the crisis, the migration of this time, the work of the miners and the work of the children in the plantations.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I would recommend pairing with Out of the Dust by Karen Hesse.

      Delete
  9. Everything You Wanted to Know About Indians But Were Afraid to Ask
    by Anton Treuer

    a. Audience for whom the book is written: Recommended for ages 12-18

    b. Audience to whom it will appeal: grades 7-12 (both an adult version and a young reader's version)

    c. Particular strengths of the book:
    -Stereotypes and multiple viewpoints are addressed by the author stating that he is NOT speaking for all Indians.
    -The book responds to 121 questions commonly assumed and asked about Indians/Native Americans.
    -The author is a Minnesotan and continues to teach at Bemidji State University as an Ojibwe professor

    d. Particular weaknesses of the book: none present

    e. Any special considerations: There are authentic pictures and sketches of Indian life, a notes section that explains some of the pictures/drawings, a table of contents and index. The author also provides a list of recommended reading and video documentaries.

    f. Verdict: A must have for any middle (young adult version) and high (adult version) school media centers because the book is a first hand/experience resource on Indian terminology, culture, religion, history, language, politics, and education.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Stamped: Racism, Antiracism, and You by Jason Reynolds and Ibram X Kendi

    Intended Audience: Grade 7+

    Actual Audience: middle grade and up

    Strengths: Written in a way that is easily understood and accessible to the audience, this book takes the history of slavery and racism and turns it into an engaging novel. This is a Young Adult adaptation of a highly decorated adult novel by Ibram X Kendi. The audio adaptation of this book includes Kendi narrating his introduction and Reynolds narrating the main body of the novel - a unique opportunity to hear the book through the voice that wrote it. Not only is the book engaging, but the research is well documented with 20 pages of resources cited at the end of the book. The novel touches on both the well-known markers of history as well as the lesser known historical moments that did not make the cut for today’s textbooks. Also, while this book is definitely written from the perspective of the author, he does put in an effort to acknowledge the viewpoint of the various historical eras he writes about.

    Weaknesses: The audiobook version does not strictly follow the book - Reynolds inserts his own commentary which makes it that much more engaging but the casualness may detract from the seriousness of the topic. (I honestly had to stretch to come up with a potential weakness because this book/audiobook is excellent)

    Special Considerations: There is a free educator’s guide available on the Amazon listing for the book. This book would work really well to make the American history textbooks more relatable and engaging to the students.

    Verdict: This is a must have book for middle and high school libraries. Not only for its curricular tie-in capabilities but also because Jason Reynolds is such an accessible writer for young adults.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wonder Women of Science: 12 Geniuses Who Are Currently Rocking Science, Technology, and the World
    Tiera Fletcher and Ginger Rue

    a & b) AUDIENCE & APPEAL This book is written for students between the ages of 9 and 12, but it appeals to middle school and high school students.

    c) STRENGTHS The book includes twelve profiles of contemporary female scientists. Each profile begins with a graphic that lists the person’s education, career, and awards, which is followed by an introduction, the “spark” or what inspired the person, the “eureka moment” or what big discovery they made, and then notes to their younger self, notes to the reader, and words to live by. Because of this structure, readers can easily navigate the text and find the information they need. It flows naturally while including biographical text and inspirational messages.

    d) WEAKNESSES Because of the word “currently” in the title and the book’s promise of sharing the stories of contemporary female scientists, this book will go out of date more quickly than other nonfiction texts. However, it is incredibly timely and relevant for the 2020s.

    e) SPECIAL CONSIDERATIONS This book can be linked to many science courses, including biology, astronomy, physics, chemistry, life science, and many more. It can also be linked to arts and design as it is interdisciplinary and mentions the importance of STEAMD, which stands for Science, Technology, Engineering, Mathematics, and Design. Additionally, there are photographs, illustrations, and other colorful graphics that make this book really engaging.

    f) VERDICT Secondary libraries need to have this book available for their students interested in the way the world works. It is especially necessary for middle school and high school girls as it reassures them of their capabilities, inspires self-confidence, and demonstrates the positive effects of determination.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Blood and Germs: The Civil War Battle Against Wounds and Disease
    Gail Jarrow

    Intended Audience: 10-17 years
    Actual Audience: 12-18

    Strengths: The book goes super in depth about the history of medicine during the civil war. The author explains in detail what a surgeon's life was like during the era and all of the medical discoveries resulting from the war.

    Weaknesses: Although the photographs are wonderful, there are some that are a bit graphic, such as photos of amputated limbs and soldiers with gangrene.

    Special Considerations: This book has received many awards including:
    -Siebert Honor Winner
    -YALSA/ALA Excellence in Nonfiction nominee
    -Kirkus reviews best books of 2020
    -2021 Outstanding Science Trade Books for Students —National Science Teaching Association & Children’s Book Council

    Verdict: I think "Blood and Germs" is an extremely informative nonfiction book that would be a great addition to any secondary library.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood by Trevor Noah

    Audience for whom the book is written: ages 14+, grades 9+

    Audience to whom it will appeal: ages 14+, grades 9+; there is also a middle grade (5th-8th) young readers’ edition

    Particular strengths of the book: Trevor Noah’s voice is the star of this book. He is witty, honest, and vulnerable, and he offers readers an authentic and personable lens through which to understand the experience of growing up in South Africa as the country dealt with apartheid and its aftermath. The experiences that Trevor went through are certainly unique, but they touch on important and universal themes with which readers from all backgrounds can relate. Though this is a nonfiction title, it reads with so much intrigue and character that it becomes easy to get lost in the story; Trevor Noah ensures that his autobiography is not boring or dry in any way. This is an excellent title for both piquing student interest and integrating into the classroom. Racism, prejudice, political and social unrest, religion, and other important topics are all touched upon in a stark and vulnerable way, with Noah’s interesting experiences acting as an anchor.

    Particular weaknesses of the book: It should be noted that there are swear words used; they are not used flippantly and are often additive or natural in context, but it is important to be aware of when considering young readers.

    Any special considerations (artwork, curriculum links, community values, beliefs espoused, etc.): The publisher, Penguin Random House, has a teacher’s guide that explains how to incorporate this book into the classroom, stating, “Supporting the national Common Core State Standards (CCSS) in reading informational text for high school curriculums, Born a Crime is an appropriate selection for grades 11 and 12 in Language Arts or World History classes.”

    https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/537515/born-a-crime-by-trevor-noah/9780399588198/teachers-guide/#:~:text=Supporting%20the%20national%20Common%20Core,Arts%20or%20World%20History%20classes.

    When considering for a classroom setting, it may be pertinent to teach that there are other viewpoints to the topics Noah discusses, since Noah’s thoughts and opinions are clear throughout.

    Verdict: Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood by Trevor Noah is a must for any high school library collection (the young readers’ edition is great for students grades 5+); it is a witty, vulnerable, and important autobiographical account of growing up in South Africa and the effects of apartheid, making it an important title for any library or classroom. Further, students will be drawn in by Noah’s fresh, contemporary writing.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Stamped: Racism, Ant-Racism, and You
    by Jason Reynolds & Ibram X. Kendi
    Audiobook narrated by Jason Reynolds

    a. Intended audience: 6th-12th grade

    b. Audience appeal: ages 12 and up

    c. Strengths: Accessible, engaging, powerful, listens like a podcast.

    d. Weaknesses

    e. Special considerations: Book or audiobook would be an excellent addition to any social studies curriculum

    f. Verdict: This is not only a must-have in a young adult library collection, but should be a must-read. Whether in print or audio format, readers will gain an understanding of racism, anti-racism and the moments in history that have influenced both.

    ReplyDelete

Welcome Fellow Readers!

...I am excited for your posts to start appearing as you read your way through ED 625 this semester. Remember, in this blog, you are reflect...